Gillies paints a picture within a picture (on an easel) against a flat, pale board within an interior. In the picture, which is his and provides the whole subject for his second picture, there is perspectival space in which his pots, leaves and lamp consort in a series of rectangles and parabolic shapes. In this picture, depth is merely indicated by the shallow shadow of the easel crosspiece against the board. The playfulness and winning palette of creams, ochres and dun colour, make for an entirely satisfying composition. It derives from Braque, but is characteristic of Gillies’ spritely, crisp drawing with the brush and his wit and restraint in posing his subject. His upcycled frame is a typical, valuable addition to his time-derived aesthetic.

Sir William Gillies was the dominant figure of the Edinburgh School over which both his personality and his work had a quiet authority. He led by example at the College of Art, encouraging his students to experiment but from a firm grounding in looking, and of course practice, drawing in particular. He also selected his staff to reflect this ethos: men and women who had a similar independence but respected hard work, what William MacTaggart called the good habit. The duties of teaching for Gillies and many of his colleagues in the School of Drawing and Painting were combined with their own practice without conflict; being a professional painter: working and exhibiting, was understood as integral to the reputation and health of the School. Robin Philipson, Elizabeth Blackadder, John Houston, David Michie and James Cumming were the beneficiaries of this attitude, along with their students, quietly instilled by Gillies over his fifty years of influence.